When Scientists Speak, Who Listens?
Below is an Op-Ed written by Robert Walker, President of the Population Institute, regarding the derision and rhetorical attacks that have been launched against the Royal Society report “People and Planet”. It was published in the Huff Post. See: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/robert-walker/when-scientists-speak-who_b_1471423.html
When Scientists Speak, Who Listens?
Scientists get no respect these days. When they speak, no one listens. It doesn’t matter how many scientists are speaking, what they are saying, or what their qualifications are, they get a fraction of the media attention lavished on a reality TV star or an American Idol contestant. Three thousand scientists and experts, including a number of Nobel Laureates, joined together and issued a warning several weeks ago about the planet and possible “catastrophic consequences” for global civilization, but Kim Kardashian and her alleged marriage woes stole the headlines. The Royal Society, the world’s oldest and most distinguished academy of science, late last month issued a report on how increasing population and rising consumption are imperiling the planet. Sir John Sulston, the Nobel Prize Laureate who chaired the working group,cautioned about a possible “downward vortex of economic, socio-political and environmental ills,” but his warning got less press attention in the U.S. than Mitt Romney’s dog.
If scientists get any media attention it’s only because the science-deniers are ridiculing them. When the Royal Society produced its “Population and the Planet,” report, the ink was not even dry before the critics were slashing away at it. A writer for The Economist declared, “On the whole it stinks.” A self-described “global expert on the metal scandium,” asserts in Forbes and The Telegraph, that it is “an appallingly bad report” and “a dismal failure.” Really? Did anyone actually read the report, or look at the credentials of those who wrote it? Doubtful.



